|
The OdysseyRating:
Release Date: 18 September, 2001 Retail Price: $14.98 OUR Price: $9.99 You SAVE: $4.99! Cast: Complete Cast (14 total) |
The Odyssey Reviews
Good, faithful adaptation
In the comentary, the director upfront admitts wishing to focus on the most entertaining parts of the Odyssey and this he does. I do not believe their is much to criticize (although there are some to be done) given the fact that even with scenes removed the runtime of the film is close to four hours. Therefore credit is due for fitting as much as they did.
The real strength of the movie is its staying true to the core story. Unlike myth/ancient history movies that have come up in the last few years such as Gladiator, Troy, and Alexander, which are mostly rationalized assumptions of the stories they are supposed to tell, the Odyssey stays true to the events that are written. Even little things that really don't bear a great deal on the movie (e.g. Athena being Mentor, the scar on Odysseus' leg, and Nausika finding Odysseus on the shore) are kept to ensure the purity of events.
Another nice point is the talent used in this movie. Despite the effects being about 10 years old, they do not overly dominate like most multi-million dollar effects movies today. Unlike the before mentioned movies who star the current most-popular eye candy of the time to garner support for the movie, such as Orlando Bloom, Brad Pitt, and Angelina Jolies, the performers have more a theatre (and thus more credible ability) background.
Isabella Rossillini stays true to Athena's playful toying part, Bernadette Peters is sassy and seductive as Kirke ought to be, and Vanessa Williams, though not the "fair-haired" as her epitath always calls her, but is exotic enough to make a convincing Kalypso.
As for the critiques, they are few, and mostly scene modifications.
1) Poseidon's grudge against Odysseus is his blasphemy, though in the book it is primarily the blinding of Polyphemus. This is touched in the movie, when the Kyklops calls his father to avenge him, but is never addressed. It would have been better to keep it so.
2)The sheep of Helios is missing, but I believe that Karybdis is a much better effect, so that omisssion is more than forgivable.
3) We always see the olive tree, but its importance should have been stressed. Penelope uses it to test Odysseus when he comes home. They could have cut out some of the lovey-duvey dialogue at the end to add that scene-it would only take about 30 seconds.
4) The scene where Ares and Aphrodite are caught in bed by Hephestatus is a funny scene, and helps to explain why Odysseus eventually makes it home without Poseidon's interference. The movie on a whole does all its sex scenes tastefully, and this one could have been as well, unlike Rome and Troy where it is graphic sex for the sake of gratuitous sex.
5) They might have thrown in Odysseus' conversation with Agamemnon in the underworld about being stabbed in the back by his wife, Klytemnestra, as it would help the drama when later Odysseus admits misgivings about Penelope's faithfulness to him to Athena. On the other hand, the scene in the underworld from the book is mostly a list of the procession of Persephone and the movie captures the most important parts of the chapter.
Finally there are the sets. The boats are modeled after realistic triremes, and the paintings on the houses, especially Menalaus', are close to accurate. The layout of Odysseus' home complete with the Andron, and the women's quarters upstairs, and the bouletarion with Odysseus' throne shows that their set designer actually did some research (another trait often lacking in blockbuster films on ancient epics)
All in all, one of the best examples of ancient epic/mythology in the media out. It stays more close to the original material, and anytone who is familiar with the work of Homer will enjoy it. Academic it may not be, but it is sucessful being entertaining as promised, but also telling the story as Homer probably wanted it to be told.
A Wasted Voyage
Although the book version of the Odyssey was capturing, the movie was rather disappointing because they left out quite a few scenes and changed the story a bit in some parts, which made it rather dull.
The movie begins as Odysseus son, Telemachus, Alan Stenson, is being born. Soon afterwards, he is drafted into the Trojan War for 11 years. He thinks he defeated the Trojans because of his crafty idea. However this angers the gods and curses his voyage home. Odysseus, Armand Assante, and his crew face many difficult trials and are away from home for almost 20 years. When they finally return, many suitors are trying to marry his faithful wife, Penelope, Greta Scacchi, and take over his land. Odysseus eventually reclaims his family and pride.
The book and movie versions of the Odyssey are similar in some ways. For example the war at Troy, the cursed voyage, the Cyclops encounter, detainment on Circe's Island, the sea monsters, and Odysseus final return to Ithaca, his home, to drive away the suitors are in both the book and movie.
However, there are quite a few differences, or things they left as well. For example, while on his way to free his men from Circe, Hermes tells him he will lay with her before hand, but leaves out that he should make her promise not to play any tricks on him. In addition, Circe does not warn Odysseus of the monsters or sirens. (Or what to do when facing them.) However, when Odysseus enters the underworld as commanded by Circe, a dead prophet warns him of only the 6-headed monster. After speaking with the prophet, Odysseus does not return to Circe as he did in the book, but goes on to face the monsters. Odysseus and his crew don't pass the sirens in the movie and while facing the six-headed monster, offer a goat as a sacrifice and everyone but Odysseus is lost to it. In the book, the men are killed by Zeus because they at the cattle of Helios, the sun god. One of the final differences is at the very end. The book gives a deep description of Odysseus getting rid of his maidservants for not being loyal and laying with the suitors. However, the movie leaves this out.
I believe the differences overrule the similarities and are pretty much the same as the good and bad qualities of the movie. The good things are the similarities, and the bad are the differences. My recommendation is to read the Odyssey because it is a good book with very detailed descriptions of the characters and adventures made. However, the movie should be viewed only if there is nothing else to watch or it is part of an assignment.
More Customer Reviews (36 total)
You like The Odyssey?
|
© 2004, 2005, 2006 DVD Booty | Don't Plunder Our Cache of Booty, Matey!
Hosting made possible by donations from debt free America, debt solution, and Debt Sage
