Yar, you be here: The Guns of Navarone (Special Edition) > Customer Reviews

The Guns of Navarone (Special Edition) Customer Reviews (1 - 3 of 34 Reviews)

Good Adaptation of a Classic Novel
The Guns of Navarone was based on the classic novel of the same name by action adventure novelist Alistair MacLean. MacLean was one of the best writers of his generation and every book he wrote is still in print. He is one of the classic writers of the last half of the 20th Century.

The producers assembled a cast that included such luminaries as Gregory Peck, David Niven, Anthony Quinn and James Robertson Justice. They hired one of the best screenwriters in the business, Carl Foreman. A good movie was in the offing.

The plot of The Guns of Navarone is that of a daring commando mission to the fictional island of Navarone. There, the Germans have huge radar controlled guns. Earlier, the British landed 2,000 troops on the island of Kheros. Now, they must be withdrawn. However since the previously unknown German installation on Navarone has since gone operational, it is impossible to safely evacuate those British troops. Either the commandos succeed in sabotaging the German guns at Navarone, or the British garrison on Kheros will be forced to surrender.

The Allies assemble a crack commando unit called Force 10 to go on a do or die mission to Navarone. In the first part of The Guns of Navarone , the movie stays true to the book and is an excellent example of an action adventure suspense flick.

The main problem is that in the original novel, it was discovered that the Greek partisan Panaysis was the traitor who had sabotaged Force 10's explosives and had been leaving clues for the Germans to follow and harry Force 10 ever since the commandos first landed on Navarone. However, the producers chose to make the traitor in the movie a female or to be more precise a pair of females. This fundamentally altered MacLean's narrative . In the novel, Panaysis had played such a key role than when he was eliminated, it created tension since it now seemed to the reader that the odds against Force 10's succeeding had been raised to incredible heights. However, in the movie, the role of the traitoress was so minor that her elimination did nothing to heighten the suspense. The impact of the revealing of the traitor was reduced to that of a wet noodle.

From this point on, the movie lacked much of the suspense of the novel. The odds against success was much lower in the movie and as a result, the eventual success of Force 10 was that much less heroic. Another problem came in the casting. The British actor David Niven plays Dusty Miller, who in the novel is a drawling Texan. The American actor Gregory Peck plays the New Zealander Keith Mallory.

The Guns of Navarone is still a better than average movie owing to the good performances of the cast coupled with the great cinematography. However, it could have been a classic in its own right. Just why the producers decided to eliminate the key character of Panaysis in favor of adding female characters who were nonexistant in the original novel is not clear, although there was speculation in Hollywood at the time that one of the actresses was a girlfriend of one of the producers.

Despite this problem, The Guns of Navarone is still a good movie that is well worth your time.

the guns of navarone
The Guns Of Navarone is still as great as it was when first saw as kid. The one thing that makes this movie better than when I first saw it is that it is on a dvd, and it is in the widescreen format preserving the original theatre cinama scope production of the movie. what also makes this movie better is the directors commentary on the movie it gave me better insite of how the movie was made.
What really makes this film great is the is the cast David Niven with his Quick wit and Gregory Peck with his carisma, and the strong presents of Anthony Quinn. All three actors made a steller team that gave the movie a perfect balance that makes it a true classic.

Great WWII Classic story
I first watched this movie as a young man and enjoyed it immensely. I have seen it several times since then, and recently viewed it with my two boys who also loved this film. Although it is a little long, the Guns of Navarone contains all the classic elements for a great WWII story.

The cast is top-notch with Gregory Peck, David Niven and Anthony Quinn leading the way. The plot is riveting as a team of highly skilled soldiers infiltrates its way towards the guns. Along their journey they face many tough decisions which makes for great dialogue. The scenes where the team struggle to finalize their toughest choices are classic leadership type scenarios.

If you enjoy WWII action films, then you have to watch the Guns of Navarone - it is one of the best there is. You won't be disappointed.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Next Page