Abduction From the Seraglio - Complete OperaRating:
Release Date: 17 July, 2001 Retail Price: $39.99 OUR Price: $35.99 You SAVE: $4.00! Cast: |
Abduction From the Seraglio - Complete Opera Reviews
Is this Mozart?s Entführung aus dem Serail?
Hans Neuenfels' stagings have an irritating habitude of displeasing the audiences. His last Fledermaus in Salzburg involved the police - the director of the festival was punched by a member of the audience. Two of my friends were there and said it was the worst operatic performance of their entire life. This video is a serious candidate for this title. First of all, who is Mr.Neuenfels to re-write the dialogues? We all know how particular Mozart was about his libretti and especially in the case of this opera how demanding he was on his librettist. Worst than that - Neuenfels dialogues are longer than the original ones and it takes this comedy to loose the essential quality of comedy (timing). Also, his re-invention of the plot made the whole thing to be simply impossible to follow if you don't know the story already. It doesn't help either to use two artists for each role: a singer and an actor. It makes the stage to be incredibly crowded and it was simply unnecessary considering that the singers had better physique du rôle than the actors and were themselves good actors. Anyway, they definitely had to be because they are made to move around in a distracting manner. If the musical performance was something of particular interest, I could have overlooked the production (or turned the image off), but the fact is that it was incredibly boring. Zagrosek's conducting was acceptable in the ouverture, with good woodwind playing, but since singers appear, the orchestra starts to be recorded in too recessed a way, turning the whole thing very shallow. Also, Zagrosek's tempi are slow and his phrasing is heavy - and his cast doesn't help him. The Konstanze has a creamy voice with some beautiful mezza voce, but she is unable to make it move. The coloratura is incredibly blurred - Martern aller Arten was a martyredom to the audience. The Belmonte had a plausible voice, rather juicy, but he sounded too much the operetta tenor to my ears - his voice is a bit lacrymose and he is not very precise with divisions. Roland Bracht (Osmin), the more familar name in the cast has an imposing voice, but he is not really Mozartian and doesn't have very good low notes. The saving grace of the production is the Blonde, who has a charming bright and clear voice and is also very funny. This video has strong competition all the way - Böhm's tempi are slow and the production is a bit outdated, but he has Gruberová and Araiza. The Covent Garden video has a charming production, good conducting, a nicest Belmonte in Deon van der Walt and there is Kurt Moll, who is reason enough to watching it.
Shocking but good to see and listen
It may be schocking at the beginning to see all the characters (except the Pasha) splitted in two: the singer and the actor, and interacting in unusual ways, but you will finally enjoy it. You must take into account that this is not a typical Opera but a Singspiel that has not a rigid libretto and the dialogues are opened to improvisation. I found the two female singers (Catherine Naglestad playing Constanze and Kate Ladner playing Blonde)quite good, as well as the tenor playing Pedrillo and the baritone playing Osmin. I recommend it to all Opera lovers.
More Customer Reviews (4 total)
© 2004 DVD Booty | Don't Plunder Our Cache of Booty, Matey!
Hosting Provided by Consolidate Credit Card Debt
